You’ve spent months, maybe even years in pre-production; script development, fundraising, wrangling friends, family, strangers, following every lead just trying to wring as much production value as you can from every cent you can get your hands on. The pieces and players are all in place. You’ve “green-lit” the film and now it’s time to make you movie.
Actually it’s not.
It’s time to SHOOT your movie.
Your film isn’t a film until the final edit is complete.
You can shoot for years, (I know people who have,) you can develop and pre-produce, produce and shoot until the cows come home but until the picture is locked and handed over to the sound guys in post all you have is footage…not a film.
There is absolutely nothing like being on set. It’s a thrill to work with hundreds of people all focusing on that ” one” take. It’s stressful and exhilarating at the same time. You get to live the dream but as soon as you call a wrap on the production, the days on set “creating” with the team are over. You feel a pang of loss in your gut as your actors and crew all head off to new adventures leaving you, the producer and your new best friend, the editor, to MAKE the film.
If you are working ultra-low budget then you may be cutting your dream together yourself.
Try to avoid that at all costs.
“WHY?” (I hear you say ) “I know this project better than I know myself! I could NEVER let someone else cut my baby!?”
And that’s the exact reason why you should.
It’s all “forest for the trees” we fall in love with our own work, warts and all.
When our bad edit decisions make it into the film I can guarantee you it will be caught by the audience. It may even ruin your film and waste all the time you spent creating it.
Do you love the work of Martin Scorcese, Spike Lee, Quentin Tarantino or Robert Wise?
Then you love the work their EDITORS do.
All these guys either work or have worked with their favorite editors on all their films or at least most of them. Why? Because not only do their editors have an amazing high level of ability, but I am guessing these directors have an understanding, a second language that they can speak with their editor: they know their editor that MAKES their film.
The house analogy:
A film script is the blueprint of the film, the director the contractor who oversees the production, (the owner of the new home would be the Producer) the cast and crew are the bringing all the materials to the job site. The marble countertops, the wrought Iron stair case, the nail guns, paint and lumber.
Once all the materials are delivered to the contractors’ satisfaction the builder (the editor) steps in and puts it all together. The editor is the hands-on guy (or gal) that builds the house. A great editor can take the rough materials (your footage) and turn it into the best possible story it can be. Because they don’t come to the editing table with the same pre-conceived notions the director may have in their head, they look at the footage with fresh eyes and more importantly, fresh ideas. Sure there are differences of opinions during the edit. That’s how great decisions are made. If it was easy everyone could do it right? And I can tell you not everyone can be a great editor. It’s an art and talent as well as a highly developed skill.
Like screenwriting, and every other role in a film, editing is a craft.
Different editors may be better at drama, action or comedy. I have found some editors who have a specialty. They have that “feel” for the material, and guess what? They find themselves cutting those kinds of films because they have proven they know what they are doing.
Just like hiring your Director of Photography, I would look at any editor’s film reel with an eye to the type of material you are going to be a shooting. Talk at length about films that are similar or styles you like. If have good communication going in you may have found yourself a partner. You’re going to be in it with your choice for the long haul.
If this sounds like marriage …it is. You’re trying to CREATE something with this person.
A good editor can turn a cardboard shack into a better-looking cardboard shack but a great editor can work miracles and turn that shack into a Craftsman style, Tudor, or Romanesque dream house.
A good editor knows pacing and composition and especially continuity and story structure.
A bad editor can ruin the best scenes. I don’t care how much you spent, or who is in your film. Get a lousy editor (our cut it yourself in a lousy way) and your film is doomed. A bad edit can turn an oscar-worthy script into straight-to-DVD B-film.
Best case scenario: get an editor in pre-production and have them start cutting as soon as the lab cranks out your footage (if you’re shooting a film) or dump those takes on a hard drive from your digi-cam and hand them off to your editor ASAP.
Your movie can start taking shape immediately. Get scenes cut while you are still shooting. Your editor may spot holes that you can fix while still in production. It’s incredibly expensive to re-shoot scenes after principal photography has ended, so why not try to avoid those issues? Plus, you can screen edited scenes after a day of shooting, make suggestions to your editor and get an idea how your shots are flowing.
Want to get a rush of adrenaline about the project while you are in the trenches shooting? Watch a few well-cut dailies.
Filmmaking is collaborative and if you are not collaborating with an editor you are missing out on 90% of what your film “could” be.
Ask around. There are great editors waiting to be discovered.
Your film and audience will thank you for it.

